Post Info TOPIC: JUST A BIT PEED-OFF!
Who thinks the seat belt rules need to be ammended? [29 vote(s)]

YES THEY DO
96.6%
NO, THEY ARE FINE THE WAY THEY ARE
3.4%


sponsor

Status: Offline
Posts: 497
Date:
RE: JUST A BIT PEED-OFF!


Yep, I agree. If a vehicle is involved in an accident where the chief scruitineer decides that the force of the impact was sufficient to have damaged the belts (ie, they may have stretched), then I think the belts should be cut so they can no longer be used.

__________________



Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 354
Date:

There were belts around in the past that had a "tuck" sewn into them. The stiching would break after a certain force impact. When the stich broke it would expose a red tag which meant that the belt should not be used again.

Scrutineers are not allowed to cut belts as it constitutes damage to property which is not theirs. All sorts of legal issues. Can't be done.

__________________


sponsor

Status: Offline
Posts: 497
Date:

Well, if they can't cut the belts, then note in the log book that new belts must be installed before the car can race again.

__________________



Forum Addict

Status: Offline
Posts: 91
Date:

A dead give away which I always go by is that all belts have brand patches sewn onto them If the stitching has been torn the belt has been stretched as the patch doesn't stretch at the same rate as the webbing it's sewn onto.

__________________
"I'm dangerous when i'm cornered. I fall to pieces so quickly people get hit by the schrapnel" Zaphod Beeblebrox - Galactic President


In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 198
Date:

maybe a system similar to the one used on helmets is needed where after a big impact a patch is removed to show a void label

__________________

I have one speed one gear......GO



Powerhouse Poster

Status: Offline
Posts: 48
Date:

 Hey Steve,
     My impact with the tree at Milbrodale was fairly harsh and my belts had only done about 100kms racing but i think it should be up to the scrutineers at the event of the accident should make the decision if you should replace them or not. I myself would be happy to replace mine after an impact like i had .The impact i had was enough to bend the internals of the car back behind the seatsl, the seats have broken out of the car and the floor of the car is buckled so much that my stubby lids fall through to the shed floor. Hopefully my next scans are good next week so i can start physio and get rid of the crutches and my navigator no longer has the neck brace on but has to be very carefull for the couple of months.

Attachments
__________________
Paul Johnson


In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 191
Date:

that looked big paul. says a lot of how well barry builds a car hope all is well with you and your nav

__________________
NEV TAYLOR


Powerhouse Poster

Status: Offline
Posts: 48
Date:

Everything will be good, The car wil be ready for next years racing, Hopefully with an a arm on it. I am a bit restricted with what i can do  at the moment but once i can walk again it will be all systems go. you know what i mean.



__________________
Paul Johnson


sponsor

Status: Offline
Posts: 497
Date:

Wow, that is a huge hit... Glad you are both ok, though obviously feeling the effects of it for a while to come.

Not sure that I have seen a car that bent without having been rolled, etc. It does say a lot for the build of the car that after such a big hit that all are ok.

__________________



Forum Addict

Status: Offline
Posts: 91
Date:

Trekka273 wrote:

Wow, that is a huge hit... Glad you are both ok, though obviously feeling the effects of it for a while to come.

Not sure that I have seen a car that bent without having been rolled, etc. It does say a lot for the build of the car that after such a big hit that all are ok.



You obviously didn't see Owen Andersons attempt to fell a tree at Mildura a few years ago. It all goes to show the crumpling effect of the car sacrificing itself to protect you.

btw, I'd bin the belts and buy new ones. They've done their job.

 



__________________
"I'm dangerous when i'm cornered. I fall to pieces so quickly people get hit by the schrapnel" Zaphod Beeblebrox - Galactic President


Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 1989
Date:

frockkkkkkk.... hope you're up an about without crotches soon.

__________________

Green Sally up. Green Sally down.
Lift and squat, gonna tear the ground.



Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 1057
Date:

These injuries sound pretty serious, not to pry, but what IS wrong (physio and crutches, neck braces), must be more serious than what you're letting on?

Might be best not to go to milbrodale in the future, dont wear green undies, go back to 1650 class?

__________________


Powerhouse Poster

Status: Offline
Posts: 48
Date:

The problem with my leg is the impact punched the bottom of my leg into the base of my knee and fractured the bone , so i have a full brace on my left leg which allows me to bend my knee 30 degrees but cannot put any weight on it untill the fracture repairs itself. The force on the clutch pedal blew the seals out of the slave cylinder. As for Scott my navigator the CT scan at hospital showed some cloudiness on 3 discs in his neck but no serious damage, He just has to be carefull with his movements for a while. You are right about Milbrodale , it hasn't been good for me in the last couple of years, I might have to change engines and drop back a class, We'll see.

__________________
Paul Johnson


In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 165
Date:

that straight and bazco's dont mix i can vouch for that, Glad to hear you two are on the mend. as for the seat belts i have a shed full the bloody things and i only have to replace one at a time. Mabe we could all get togeather and and make the guinness book of world records for the most wasted seat belts in a line or somthing ?

Attachments
__________________


Powerhouse Poster

Status: Offline
Posts: 37
Date:

I think the seatbelts need something in them that is definitive (sailing harnesses have an oveload strip, which is essentially a label, when the stitching pulls ouf of the tab its been overloaded and is no longer useable), otherwise its all too subjective, add into that mix that some of the scrutineers also run businesses selling seatbelts, and it becomes a shady issue. It cant be the scrutineers decision (unless you ban scrutineers with vested interests, but the guys in the business are often the most knowledgable), it has to be in the belt, or let people deal with it, at the end of the day, as long as its only you in the belt, it shouldnt matter, take responsibility for your own actions. That said why does my road car seatbelt never expire? it spends its entire life in the sun and is thinner webbing, but its good to go forever.

As a side note I have had some luck selling old belts on ebay, they generally recoup about half of the new cost of a belt, takes the sting out of it I guess.

__________________


In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 246
Date:

Hey Paul
This year I was in a buggy out on the course so did not get a video for you. Sorry mate - Blacky

__________________

95% of the money I ever earned I spent on drugs, alcohol and hookers. The rest I wasted.



Regular Poster

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

The following appears in the minutes of the August meeting of the Vic State Rally Council Executive, as part of the report :

1. Safety Harnesses.
On the basis of testing conducted by the Australian Institute of Motor Sport Safety, the Board has agreed to extend the working life of a safety harness, when used in non-international competition to ten years from the date of manufacture. An announcement is in preparation, which will emphasise the existing condition that it is the responsibility of the competitor to ensure that his equipment is in good working order, and that any harness which shows visible signs of deterioration will be rejected by event scrutineers.

This is from a Rally meeting - but the "Board" I expect is the CAMS Board.

I'll let you know if I hear anything else....

__________________


Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 1989
Date:

starting to move inthe right direction!

__________________

Green Sally up. Green Sally down.
Lift and squat, gonna tear the ground.



In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 197
Date:

The Minutes referred to by Marty are a little misleading and we should not get too excited about any of this.

The AIMSS (Australian Institute of Motor Sport Safety) had some testing conducted on the FAI type belts and there may possibly be an announcement from the CAMS Board in due course which will recommend based on this testing that the "age limit" on the FAI Belts be accepted as up to 10 years. I don't know the full extent of the recommendations and the imminent decision from the Board will result in a detailed press release giving clarification.

Whilst this may be good news for those who choose to use FAI type belts, it doesn't offer anything to those who use SFI type belts, which is predominately what we all use in off road racing.

Now, you may be asking yourselves, why did the AIMSS only test the FAI type belts and not look at the SFI type belts? The answer to that i guess is in where they got the funding to conduct the testing. The funding came from an assortment of motorsport clubs who are predominately involved in circuit racing type activities where they all use the FAI type belts.



Marty wrote:

The following appears in the minutes of the August meeting of the Vic State Rally Council Executive, as part of the report :

1. Safety Harnesses.
On the basis of testing conducted by the Australian Institute of Motor Sport Safety, the Board has agreed to extend the working life of a safety harness, when used in non-international competition to ten years from the date of manufacture. An announcement is in preparation, which will emphasise the existing condition that it is the responsibility of the competitor to ensure that his equipment is in good working order, and that any harness which shows visible signs of deterioration will be rejected by event scrutineers.

This is from a Rally meeting - but the "Board" I expect is the CAMS Board.

I'll let you know if I hear anything else....







__________________


Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 1057
Date:

I have used FIA belts in the past, they would probably only be about twice the price of SFI belts, and if ammended, we will get 5 times the life span......bring it on!

__________________


Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 1989
Date:

can you get them in lever latch?

__________________

Green Sally up. Green Sally down.
Lift and squat, gonna tear the ground.



In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 197
Date:

Wolf wrote:

can you get them in lever latch?



As far as i am aware, there are no Lever/Latch type to the FAI standard.

Just something i would like to clarify for everyones interest as well. Someone stated in this forum that there is no difference in the webbing used in FAI belts as opposed to SFI belts. This is incorrect. They are a different type of material. This was one of the first things we asked to be clarified many years ago when this first raised it's ugly head.



__________________
dan


Forum Junkie

Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Date:

Interestingly enough Tassie, I have four sets of GForce Pro Series belts that came from Cameron at Racer, and they have BOTH SFI and FIA certification!! (they are rotary buckle however)


-- Edited by dan at 18:37, 2008-09-19

__________________


Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 1057
Date:

I had rotary buckle belts for several years berore the stupid 2 year rule was brought in...some people said the buckles get dirt in them and play-up a bit!
I found mine excellent in every way, NEVER did the latch not work, and getting in after a break down was much quicker to 'harness-up' again.
I am not 'fussey' with my belts, and they only get removed from the car after 2 years (pressure cleaned in the car etc), but I wouldnt hesitate in going back to the FIA belts!

__________________


Regular Poster

Status: Offline
Posts: 24
Date:

CAMS have issued a Bulletin today.

http://www.cams.com.au/bulletins/B08-105%20Schedule%20I%20-Safety%20Harnesses.pdf

I don't know how it affects you... but it's saved me a couple of hundred bucks!

__________________


Forum Junkie

Status: Offline
Posts: 146
Date:

I will be fitting FIA approved belts in my buggy as soon as it is ready to race again

__________________


Rehab Dropout...

Status: Offline
Posts: 354
Date:

Tas, I said the webbing was the same. I got the information from a company called Klippan. They make harnesses. At the time they were considering making an SFI lever-latch belt. They told me that if they went ahead with production the material would be the same as the FIA spec belts.

If a belt has an SFI & FIA tag on it why would we assume that it was good for five years & not two? All this bullshit started because SFI meant two years. The situation of duel tags requires a ruling by CAMS to say that FIA over rules SFI if both tags are present. Otherwise a scrutineer would be obliged to say that the belts are only good for two years, otherwise you would be ignoring the SFI recomendation & we couldn't do that could we?

__________________


In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 197
Date:

Okay, now it might be time to get excited.

It seems the AIMSS may now arrange for the testing of harnesses complying with the SFI standard.

Hoepfully, we can get a similiar result from the testing and support from the CAMS Board?

__________________


In rehab

Status: Offline
Posts: 208
Date:

This Media Release may give hope.

AIMSS ACHIEVES A MAJOR BENEFIT FOR CAMS COMPETITORS


A JOINT CAMS / AIMSS MEDIA RELEASE

The Australian Institute for Motor Sport Safety (AIMSS) has succeeded in achieving a major cost-cutting benefit while maintaining optimum safety levels in the area of safety harness life in Australian motor sport.

Following a recommendation by AIMSS, the Confederation of Australian Motor Sport Ltd (CAMS) Board has approved an extension of the validity of FIA racing harnesses in non-international events from five to ten years.

The amendment to CAMS regulations is effective immediately, and will ease a substantial cost burden for most CAMS competitors. Competitors in FIA international competition will still be required to comply with the five-year restriction.

At the suggestion of its National Technical Committee, earlier this year CAMS requested that AIMSS undertake a scientific study of this issue. Previous studies known to AIMSS had raised the possibility that the validity period for non-international CAMS-sanctioned competition might be extended, if justified by its new research.

AIMSS contracted Autoliv, a major FIA-approved crash and equipment test laboratory, to examine and test a wide variety of competition harnesses that could no longer be used as their validity had expired. The ages of harnesses tested ranged from six to approximately thirty years.

The results demonstrated that there was no measurable deterioration in webbing or harness component strength for many years after the end of the five-year validity period, and none within a ten-year period.

AIMSS will now arrange for the testing of harnesses complying with the American SFI specification, which are very popular among off-road competitors. Currently, the webbing for these harnesses must be renewed every two years and it is possible, although as yet unproven, that this period might also be safely extended.

AIMSS Chairman Dr Michael Henderson welcomed the approval by CAMS of the Institutes recommendation.

AIMSS is a research and educational organisation and we totally understand the cost pressures on competitors, especially at national and club level, said Dr Henderson.

Safety must be affordable, and we are joining with the FIA in further international studies of cost-benefit issues facing motor sport safety.

CAMS CEO Graham Fountain agreed that the outcome for most Australian competitors will be greatly welcomed.

This is a great outcome and cost saving for competitors across all areas of motor sport in Australia, particularly at the club level of the sport, said Fountain.

This clearly demonstrates the value of AIMSS and the commitment of CAMS to pursue improvements which result in the maintenance of a safety-first environment while providing real savings for competitors.

We are committed to continuing this approach and AIMSS is already working on protocols to extend these harness studies and use similar methodology to examine other safety regulations.

Other projects recently undertaken by AIMSS, with some soon to be reported, include the effects of carbon monoxide and heat stress, mass data processing of CAMS incident and injury reports, and a review of rollover protection requirements.

AIMSS has also recently presented several workshops on the use of head and neck restraint devices, and last year held Australias first motor sport safety seminar.

ABOUT AIMSS

The Confederation of Australian Motor Sport (CAMS) has founded the Australian Institute for Motor Sport Safety (AIMSS) to promote improvements in the safety of motor sport and the relationship between motor sport and road safety in Australia.

The Institute, which is a non-regulatory body, aims to encourage excellence across all aspects of motor sport safety through research, education, and the co-ordination of safety-related programs. Its formation provides an important step in the evolving history of safety in motor sport.

AIMSS was launched by Sir Jackie Stewart at the 2007 Australian Grand Prix, and is now accredited as a Research Partner Organisation for the FIA Institute for Motor Sport Safety.



__________________


Regular Poster

Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Date:

How long will the testing of the SFI belts take to be done, My 2 years(5 races) on my current belts are up and would like to do one more race before the end of he season without buying new belts that will then sit in the car for 5 months unused. Any ideas

__________________
«First  <  1 2 3  >  Last»  | Page of 3  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us
Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard