It is all in the interpretation of the rules and I suggest everyone to READ the bulletin not just look at the pictures!
The COMPULSORY roof support bar to the top of the A pillar was made compulsory for all vehicle at the start of the 2009 year so it doesn't need to be stated in this bulletin again.
The straight bar from the rear hoop to the front leg appears on diagram 4.2b to also attach to the compulsory roof support bar so if your car has a straight hip rail / waste bar you can attach the compulsory roof bar to the new Upper Side Bar and join it back into the original hip rail where that bar was previously fitted.
The new Upper Side Bar is allowed to have a bend in it as described in method 2. The diagram 4.2c shows a bar with 2 bends in it but does not state how many bends can be applied to the Upper Side Bar. A single bend which mirrors the original hip rail in your car scooter can be applied as long as you have at least 1 other additional supporting member as is stated in WRITING. This additional supporting member can be the compulsory roof support bar if it allows enough entry & exit space or it can be mounted back to the floor like the diagram suggests.
My opinion is that the Roll Cage requires a horizontal bar joining the Upper Side Bars together and should be made compulsory too however it is only a suggested bar.
Mike, are you sure about the roof bar compulsary 2009? The only reason I ask is that my car does not have one & I have been to two events this year, one was a state round, & I was not logged for it.
The roof bar from the top of the A pillar to upper side bar was made compulsory but I just couldn't find it when looking on the online manual. It used to be for buggies with a 700mm or longer roof span but was changed this year so all cars had to have it which I think was a smart idea. Seriously, look at your car side on and look at the protection YOU have for yourself. While is a pain in the A__ to add bars its also for your safety!!! A mild rollover without that bar will make the roof collapse to a straight line from the roll cage to where its mounted on the upper side bar so where is that going to put your head?
We all think "it will never happen to us" and 99.99% of the time that is the case but its not worth whinging and having an arguement with anyone just because you can't be bothered to make your car safe. Im passionate about racing and want to be safe doing it but don't want the .01% to happen to me and stop me from racing for good.
Michael, can you use the roof support bar with a bend in the hip rail, because if so you would be doing the method in 4.2b, but with a bend, which it clearly states this method cannot have a bend?
i have just re read the rules and i think that method 2 would alllow us with bent hip rails to fit a new bent tube above the existing one as long as it is tied in with another support bar. i think the drawing is just misleading.
if you read it. it says a bar joining front to back with 1 support bar. it doesn't say where this bar should be located. the drawing i guess is one way you might do it. (not sure why but you might)
The way I read it is method 1 and Diagram 4.2b can only be applied if you have adequate room with a STRAIGHT bar from the rear hoop to the front leg. I would imagine that the older cars that are most likely to need to be changed will be quite narrow and fitting a straight bar will be almost impossible while maintaining sufficient room as to not bang your elbows and shoulders on the Upper Side Bar. This STRAIGHT bar does not require to be tied in according to the diagram and wording but I would suggest that it should be for increased occupant safety.
Method 2 and Diagram 4.2c gives the competitor the most amount of freedom while making it the easiest to adapt to any buggy. A bend in the Upper Side Bar is allowed and the owner of the vehicle or competitor has the DISCRETION of where the supporting bar is located! If this is adapted with the additional supporting member as per the diagram but on a single bend along the Upper Side Bar and the compulsory roof support bar also mounted to the same bend then this will make the buggy the safest in a side impact.
It depends if your rear hoop is vertical when looked at side on or is angled either forward or backward as to whether the roof support bar could be tied in to a bend in the Upper Side Bar. My car is done this way with a forward inclination of 10 degrees and will provide excellent occupant protection while enabling sufficient room while seated and for entry / exit space.
Just finished the the side intrusion up dates to my old car. $100 in steel 1x 6pak of bundy 1x sick day from work. It took longer for the paint to dry than do the job. The car is most definatly a safer thing, but it hurts the old class 3 racer in me to add so much weight to the car my navigator will need to start his diet asap
Just a question, & I don't know the answer. If someone elects to do this job themselves & makes a mess of it. Lets say they do birdtish welds & blow holes in the rear roll hoop, then grind it all up so as it looks pretty, Is the car stronger or weaker than it was before?
For the record I am not a welder so I payed someone that is to do my car.